Title: Court of Fives
Author: Kate Elliott
Information on series: First in Court of Fives trilogy
Audience: Teens, though some adults will enjoy as well
Rating (scale of 1-5, with 5 being highest): 4
TL;DR: A novel about presumptions, prejudice, and incredible athletic feats (think Ninja Warrior). A good mix of action and character-development that should appeal to dystopian fans, despite it's fantasy setting.
Longer review: If you love action-packed dystopian novels, especially those featuring rebellious teens in a battle against repressive societies, but you're feeling burned out on futuristic wastelands, this might be the book for you. Court of Fives is set in a world based in part on the societies of ancient Egypt, the Aztec empire, and ancient Rome. This is Elliott's first young adult novel, but she's written several popular series for adults.
I loved the setting, and the complex relationships between the different cultures. The city of Saryenia is ruled by a rigid class structure, where the elite are conquerors from a foreign empire (or refugees from an empire shattered by Civil War) and the commoners are the remnants of a once powerful, darker skinned native society. Intermarriage between the two groups is strictly forbidden, which puts the main character's, Jessamy's, family in a precarious position. Jessamy's father is an accomplished military commander, and her mother is a low born commoner, placing Jessamy and her sisters somewhere in between.
The story is told from Jessamy's perspective, as she struggles between her love for her family and her dreams to be a champion at the Fives, a dangerous sport similar to Ninja Warrior. If you're not sure what Ninja Warrior is, I recommend checking out this video. The fact that we see Jessamy's world so tightly from her perspective sets up some nice surprises later in the novel as we learn that Jessamy's assumptions about her sisters and their goals were not always based on truth.
There is a romantic sub-plot to the novel, and of course it is a forbidden romance. Some readers will enjoy the lack of a love triangle (at least in this first volume), but I found that the love story added a layer of distraction to a fairly packed plot. It's likely that, were I still a teen reader, I would've loved this element of the book, but as an adult, I was rolling my eyes.
Read alikes:
The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins: The big name action-packed dystopian novel, with a capable female lead on a quest to save her family.
Seraphina by Rachel Hartman: Seraphina's incredible musical talents bring her to the attentions of the royal palace as murder and political intrigue threaten to collapse the fragile peace between humans and dragons. SPOILER ALERT: Everything becomes even more complicated as Seraphina realizes she is the child of a forbidden romance between a human and a dragon.
~Sarah, Carnegie-Stout Public Library
Showing posts with label adult. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adult. Show all posts
Saturday, October 31, 2015
Wednesday, October 7, 2015
Review: Rat Queens: Sass and Sorcery by Kurtis J. Wiebe & Roc Upchurch
Title: Rat Queens: Sass and Sorcery
Author: Written by Kurtis J. Wiebe, Art by Roc Upchurch
Information on series: Volume 1 of an ongoing series
Audience: Adult. Very adult.
Rating (scale of 1-5, with 5 being highest): 5
TL;DR: A crazy thrill-ride of blood and feminism.
Longer review:
Betty, Dee, Hannah, and Violet are The Rat Queens, a party of brawling, boozing, sexing, swearing adventurers in the vaguely Euro-fantastic town of Palisade. In this first volume, they defeat an army of orcs and save the town. But the orcs were only there because they were friends of an ogre the Rat Queens viciously murdered. But the Rat Queens only murdered the ogre because the mayor of Palisade sent the ogre to kill them. But the mayor only wanted the Rat Queens dead because they kept getting drunk and starting fights. At first glance, it’s hard to figure out who the good guys are.
Ultimately, we end up siding with the Rat Queens for the simple but very compelling reason that they are a band of complex and flawed but sympathetic characters who, despite all other failings, display a sincere and contagious affection for each other. I cannot stress how rare and enjoyable this is. As a rule, filthy, bloody, drug-fueled adventure comics do not feature an all-female case. Or, if they do, the women are adolescent sex fantasies first and actual characters second. And their stories certainly don’t feature a sincere emotional core.
Rat Queens shows a mix of humor, violence, vulgarity, and heart that is absolutely atypical for fantasy comics, and I suspect it had a rough road to publication. But its reception has been great. It was nominated for an Eisner Award for Best New Series in 2014 (that’s essentially an Oscar for comics) and a Hugo for Best Graphic Story in 2015. It also picked up a 2015 GLAAD Media Award for its LGBT representation (that, more than anything else I’ve said, should quiet your worries about whether a comic with this much crass-ness can also manage some compelling character work).
The series has seen a couple artist changes since it started (for a variety of disappointing reasons that I won’t get into here). For this first volume, all the art is by co-creator Roc Upchurch. First off, his character designs are great. He splashes in modern touches like Hannah’s rockabilly-inspired hair, but melds them with more traditional fantasy elements for a good, consistent aesthetic. All four of the Rat Queens are presented as sexy at times, but they’re far from the chainmail bikini cliche of so much fantasy art.
Upchurch also does a good job laying out his pages and staging action. He’s got enough restraint and faith in the writing to stick to a fairly simple panel grid when drawing dialogue, which gives more impact to the times he throws the grid out for a splash page or action sequence. As in a movie, action in comics really falls apart without a visual storyteller who can subtly guide the reader’s eye, making sure the follow the sequence of events.
Read-alikes:
Dungeons & Dragons by John Rogers - This comics series, published by IDW starting in 2010, matches Rat Queens’ sense of fun and adventure, but dials back the adult themes. As you might expect from an official tie-in to a large media property, these comics are very well made but ultimately play it a little safe. Start with volume 1, Shadowplague.
Skullkickers by Jim Zub - An unlikely pair of adventurers seek gold and glory while facing down ever-more strange and deadly foes. Skullkickers matches the weird humor of Rat Queens but loses the emotional core.
Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set by Wizards of the Coast - Not a book so much as a box that contains several booklets, some loose sheets, and an assortment of dice. If you’re this far into fantasy about parties of heroic adventurers, maybe you should just take the plunge and give D&D a try. One of the best things about Rat Queens is the bond of friendship between the four leads. D&D is all about cooperating with your friends to tell grand stories and defeat hideous villains.
Review: California Bones by Greg Van Eekhout

Title: California Bones
Author: Greg Van Eekhout
Series: Book one in a trilogy
Audience: Adult
Rating on scale 1-5: 4
TL;DR: California Bones is a combination urban fantasy and caper novel set in dystopian California.
Longer review:
Daniel Blackland, a thief and osteomancer, is hired by a crime lord to break into a supposedly impenetrable stronghold and steal a sword. The sword was made by Daniel’s Father, a powerful magician, and possesses the magical essence of Daniel himself. Daniel’s Father was killed by the the Hierarch, the ruler of the Kingdom of Southern California. Daniel puts together the best thieves to steal the sword.
When I saw that it was an urban fantasy and a caper I was pretty excited. Since it is a caper book, it is fairly action packed. This book is gritty and a little gruesome (it’s not for the faint of heart).
Read-alikes:
Kraken: an anatomy by China Miéville. This urban fantasy also has group of magicians stealing an object. (A giant squid fom the British museum. It also described as gritty.
Monster Hunter International by Larry Correia. This urban fantasy is described as action packed and gruesome. The main character gets a job hunting monsters because monsters are real.
Dresden Files series by Jim Butcher. This action packed urban fantasy series has a Wizard private detective as its main character.
Tuesday, October 6, 2015
Review: A Darker Shade of Magic by V.E. Schwab

Title: A Darker Shade of Magic
Author: V.E. Schwab
Information on series: First of Darker shade of magic trilogy, second book expected 2016.
Audience: New Adult/Adult; possibly YA though there is some language and violence, but nothing gratuitous
Rating (scale of 1 – 10, with 10 being the highest): 9.5
Recommended to: Historical fiction readers; fans of political/royal thrillers
Tl;dr: A gritty urban fantasy set against a backdrop of parallel Londons where dark magic threatens to overtake and destroy everything, and there may be only one person who can stop it.
“Some thought magic came from the mind, others the soul, or the heart, or the will. But Kell knew it came from the blood.Review:
Blood was magic made manifest. There it thrived. And there it poisoned. Kell had seen what happened when power warred with the body, watched it darken in the veins of corrupted men, turning their blood from crimson to black. If red was the color of magic in balance—of harmony between power and humanity—then black was the color of magic without balance, without order, without restraint.
As an Antari, Kell was made of both, balance and chaos; the blood in his veins, like the Isle of Red London, ran a shimmering, healthy crimson, while his right eye was the color of spilled ink, a glistening black.”
Kell is Antari, which means he possesses special magic that allows him to pass between parallel worlds acting as courier to each of London’s different crowns. There are three Londons to which he travels: Grey, White, and Red. Grey London is the one we know with Parliament and Westminster and the Thames flowing through the city. It is a drab place with no magic, though there are those who believe it exists. White London’s river is called the Siljt and the palace is an icy fortress ruled by evil twins (literally, evil twins). In White London magic is a rare commodity, highly and viciously sought after, hoarded by those in power and taken from others at any cost. Red London has an abundance of magic and its people live in lavish luxury. It is there where Kell lives at the palace with the King, Queen and the High Prince Rhy, and is treated by others as royalty himself, though he doesn’t feel as if he truly belongs. There’s a fourth London, Black, but no one comes or goes from there anymore. When Kell journeys to White or Grey London he returns with small keepsakes and trinkets, amassing a private collection of odds and ends. Like a magpie he hoards these objects, despite Rhy’s warnings that dire consequences will come from Kell’s habit…
Lila has been surviving on her own in White London’s rough streets, stealing to stay alive and dreaming of the high seas. She wants nothing more than to be the commander of her own pirate ship, but she can barely stay afloat on land. When her path crosses Kell’s she knows there are greater adventures waiting, and she will do just about anything to be part of them.
Holland is like Kell; he can travel between the Londons and does so at the behest of White London’s rulers, Astrid and Athos Dane. Unlike Kell, Holland has little freedom even though he is Antari, and is at the mercy of the ruthless Danes who will stop at nothing to satisfy their desire for magic.
A darker shade of magic will appeal to readers of historical fiction and political thrillers who are perhaps interested in Fantasy but aren’t quite ready to submerse themselves in a completely new world. Though there are elements of more traditional fantasy, including a new language, the fantastical elements and the magical system are not overly complex.
Read alikes:
- A Study in Silks by Emma Jane Holloway, (see RART review)
- A Thousand Pieces of You by Claudia Grey
- Queen of the Tearling by Erika Johansen
Reviewer: Jillian Rutledge, Waverly Public Library
Review: The Magicians by Lev Grossman

Author: Lev Grossman
Information on series: The Magicians: Book 1
Audience: Adult
Rating (scale of 1-5, with 5 being highest): 4
TL;DR: A character driven contemporary fantasy about a high schooler who knows some magic tricks that suddenly finds himself admitted to a mysterious school of magic.
Longer review:
Quinten Coldwater, grew up enjoying a series of books about a magical make believe land called Fillory. Fillory is very similar C.S. Lewis’ Narnia. Quintin is thrilled when he is invited to join a University for magicians. Quintin excels in school but loses his innocence when a prank allows an evil being to enter the University. Quintin and his former classmates find out that Fillory is real and their skills are put to the test when they travel there.
I listened to the book and I really liked the reader. I loved Lewis’ Chronicles of Narnia as a child so I loved the fact that Quintin could actually visit Fillory.
Readalikes:
The Wicked Years series by Gregory Maguire. This series is also a character driven fantasy that re-imagines a fictional world.
The Kingkiller Chronicle series by Patrick Rothfuss. Although Rothfuss’ books take place in a different time, late medieval Europe, the main characters go to wizarding/magician school and along the way lose their innocence when they discover evil.
Running with the Demon by Terry Brooks. Both books deal with magic but they also both deal with the age-old theme, good vs evil.
Review: The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan
Title: The Lightning Thief
Author: Rick Riordan
Information on series: First of five books in the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series
Audience: Middle grade, though with plenty of appeal for readers of any age who love a good adventure story
Rating (scale of 1-5, with 5 being highest): 4
TL;DR: An action-packed quest story whose young hero was written off as a bad kid, but really he has supernatural abilities straight out of Greek myth.
Longer review:
On a recent road trip, we started and abandoned several audiobooks, nothing quite working for both of us. That is until we started The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan (as read by Jesse Bernstein). In fact, we loved it so much that when we got home before finishing the last disc, we moved from the car straight to the couch. Neither of us had been terribly excited to listen to this book, I'd started and abandoned the print edition, he'd seen the underwhelming movie adaptation, but in the end it was a highlight of our very long drive. We were looking for a book that combined adventure and humor, and that is exactly what we got.
The Percy Jackson series is based on the idea that the Greek gods of ancient myth are not only reality, they are active forces in the modern world, who still have the bad habit of having half-god children with mortal men and women. Percy Jackson (spoilers) discovers that he is the son of an unknown god, which gives him unusual powers and mark him out as a target for evil forces. That some of his special abilities (a natural aptitude for ancient Greek, hyperaccelerated reflexes) manifest as learning disorders (dyslexia, ADHD) that mark him out as a "bad kid" in the mundane world is an inspiring touch. While your average reader isn't likely to be a demigod, the message that sometimes our strengths lie in what makes us different, even if that means we can never be normal.
While I know this book, series, and author has a very large fan base, I never would've considered suggesting this series to adults before checking out the audiobook myself. That's the magic of a skilled audiobook narrator, they can take a good book and turn it into something even better.
Read alikes:
Rick Riordan: The obvious read alike, he expands on Percy Jackson's world in the Heroes of Olympus series, explores Egyptian mythology, and his newest series, Magnus Chase, which takes on norse mythology.
Gregor the Overlander by Suzanne Collins: Before she wrote The Hunger Games, Collins wrote a series about a young boy's adventures in a secret kingdom under the streets of New York City (warning: there are rats, cockroaches, and other creepy crawlies).
Hounded by Kevin Hearne: Hearne's Iron Druid Chronicles are NOT for children or young readers. This is a decidely adult urban fantasy series set in an Arizona overrun by the gods of Celtic mythology.
~Sarah, Carnegie-Stout Public Library
Sunday, August 30, 2015
Review: The Rook by Daniel O'Malley

Title: The Rook
Author: Daniel O’Malley
Information on series: First in a series (book two will be released January 2016)
Audience: Adult
Rating (scale of 1-10): 8
TL;DR: Endlessly entertaining and engrossing, The Rook has a great set-up that the rest of the book almost entirely lives up to.
Longer review: She gains consciousness in a park, shivering in the rain, bloodied and bruised, surrounded by a ring of lifeless bodies, and with no knowledge of who she is. In her pocket is a letter with only a large number one written on the outside. “Dear you,” the letter says, “the body you are wearing used to be mine, … and along with this body you have inherited certain problems and responsibilities.”
She, it turns out, is Myfanwy Thomas, a member of the Checquy, the secret organization that keeps Britain safe from the supernatural, the paranormal and the just plain weird. In her position as a Rook, a high-ranking member of the Checquy leadership, Myfanwy discovered a traitor in the ranks but was unable to expose them before being attacked and having her memory obliterated. Thankfully she’s the sort of person to think ahead, hence the letter in her pocket - and that’s not the only one. Further letters direct the new Myfanwy to a safehouse and provide information about the Checquy and her own past. If she wants to survive the traitor's next attempt on her life, Myfanwy will have to go into work as if nothing happened, and find a way to expose them.
But when you work for the Checquy, even a normal day means fighting all sorts of weirdness: like a cult that unleashes a man-eating fungus, or a hatching dragon egg. Few of the crises she faces, however, are more terrifying than her co-workers. There's the vampire, the guy who can excrete nerve gas, the one being that inhabits four separate human bodies, and even Myfanwy herself, who finds that in times of great stress she can disrupt the bodily functions of other people - make them go blind, or stop moving, or even stop their hearts beating.
Normally, amnesia as a plot device leaves me cold, but the letters that Myfanwy reads from her past self provide a great way for the author to outline the Checquy’s history, and provide details about how his world works. Myfanwy goes into each new situation with just as much ignorance as the reader does, so even though the world of The Rook feels complex and deep, you get to experience it for the first time right along with the main character.
The tone of the novel is rather light and fun; if this were a Bond movie, it would be from the Roger Moore years and have lots of bad puns and innuendo. The dialog is snappy, sometimes a little too unrealistically crisp, and Myfanwy is thrown from crisis to crisis fast enough that she doesn’t do much in the way of seriously connecting with other characters. Hopefully the second book will see Myfanwy build some relationships and experience some development to go along with battling whatever new supernatural horror may threaten the British Isles.
Read Alikes:
Going Postal by Terry Pratchett: Con-man Moist von Lipwig is saved from deserved execution for his crimes and is subjected to a punishment that amounts to a fate worse than death - he’s put in charge of the decrepit post office system. This is the first of Pratchett’s Discworld novels featuring Moist who, like Myfanwy, is thrust into an inscrutable government institution and just has to learn as he goes along.
The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde: Thursday Next is an officer in the government department of Literary Detection, where she chases forgers and plagiarists. But one conniving baddie is bent on messing around with classic novel Jane Eyre, by kidnapping characters out of the original manuscript. To preserve England’s literary heritage, Thursday must jump into the pages of classic literature where, it turns out, she finds a shadowy agency which polices books from the inside.
Reviewed by Seth, Ames Public Library
Wednesday, August 26, 2015
Review: The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N.K. Jemisin

Author: N.K. Jemisin
Information on series: First in The Inheritance Trilogy
Audience: Adult, though with appeal for some older teens
Rating (scale of 1-5, with 5 being highest): 3.5
TL;DR: A dark love story set against a complicated backdrop of political intrigue where the stakes are life or death.
Longer review: N.K. Jemisin's debut novel, The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms, introduces a complex world of political intrigue where it is deadly dangerous to be among the elite or too far outside the norm. Unfortunately Yeine, our protagonist, is a descendant of both the ruling Arameri and the "barbaric" Darre. Centuries past, the Arameri conquered the world with the aid of the god of light, Itempas, and suppressed all other religions- and gods. Yeine's mother gave up a position of power as the Arameri heir to marry a Darre man, and lived out her life in exile for her choice. But shortly after her mother is murdered, Yeine is called to the capital by her grandfather to join the competition to become his new heir.
This is not an easy read. It is dark and sometimes confusing. I almost abandoned The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms before I finished it, but I stuck with it from a combination of sheer stubbornness and the appeal of the twisted romantic subplot. I am a sucker for any variation on the story of Psyche and Cupid, though this is more of a hint than anything close to a retelling. Fair warning, this book does contain a sex scene and there are no warm fuzzies. Everyone has hidden motivations; if morality is a spectrum, most characters lean away from the good end of the scale.
While The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms stands well on its own, readers will probably appreciate seeing how the story of these characters and their world plays out over the next two books in The Inheritance Trilogy. There is a diversity of cultures to this world that we are first led to believe is a mono-culture under the strict control of the Arameri. That Yeine's Darre people secretly hold some of their ancient beliefs and practices along with their darker complexions is easily assumed to be an exception. Jemisin created a very detailed world for this series, and it was difficult to appreciate or (for me, at times) to even grasp all of the meaning in a single reading. By looking at the same world, and some of the same events, from different perspectives in the second and third books, I gained a much clearer picture of the larger story.
That said, the murkiness of this book, where I was never quite sure of the motivations behind various characters actions or what their goals were, fit the themes of balance between light and dark or order and chaos rather well. That Yeine is trying to navigate this precarious, ill-defined space in her identity as outsider and elite, serves to emphasize the theme. This is one of several themes that Jemisin continues to examine and expand on throughout the series. I may've picked up The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms for a romantic fantasy, but I love The Inheritance Trilogy for a complexity that continues to make me think.
~Sarah, Carnegie-Stout Public Library
Read alikes:
The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin: The first book in her third series, which was just published in August, The Fifth Season also features unique worldbuilding (the main magical power is literally worldbuilding or at least a power over mountains, earthquakes, etc.), and a main character whose powers make her an outsider.
The Emperor's Soul by Brandon Sanderson: A novella length story featuring an unusual female protagonist trapped by the ruling elite. A faster-paced story with more of an emphasis on action, but still featuring well developed, complex characters that touches on some interesting questions of identity.
Friday, August 21, 2015
Genre Study Review: A Study in Silks

Title: A Study in Silks
Author: Emma Jane Holloway
Series: The Baskerville Affair
Audience: Teen / New Adult
Rating: 5
TL;DR: Evelina Cooper, Sherlock Holmes’ niece, must discover a murderer while concealing her magical talents from London’s ruthless Steam Barons.
Longer review:
Imagine yourself a young Victorian woman who has been raised in a traveling circus, taken in by an estranged grandmother when your parents died, and discovered that you have magical talents in a society that still burns witches at the stake.
Evelina Cooper has many secrets which would get her ostracized from “proper” London society, should they become known. Fortunately, she has an understanding best friend in society darling Imogen Roth, daughter of Lord Bancroft.
It becomes very hard for Evelina to keep her secrets, however, when a servant is viciously murdered at Lord Bancroft’s estate. When Evelina finds the body, she discovers that the murdered woman was carrying an envelope with traces of magic on it. Determined to protect Imogen and her family, Evelina conceals the evidence, and plots to find the murderer.
Things get much more complicated when Nick, a close friend from Evelina’s circus days comes back into her life, and Tobias Roth, Imogen’s older brother, realizes that Evelina might be more than just his little sister’s best friend.
Evalina’s investigation leads her into a world of murderous marionettes, a manipulative evil sorcerer, and the cut-throat politics of the Steam Barons of London. Even with the help and protection of the renowned Sherlock Holmes, Evelina may be out of her depth.
Author’s Website: http://www.emmajaneholloway.
Read alikes:
Dearly, Departed by Lia Habel
A Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray
The Clockwork Scarab by Colleen Gleason
Reviewed By: Teresa Dahlgren, Waterloo Public Library
Review: Long Black Curl by Alex Bledsoe

Title: Long Black Curl
Author: Alex Bledsoe
Information on series: Third book in series, after “The Hum and the Shiver” and “Wisp of a Thing.”
Audience: Adult
Rating: 4
TL;DR: Exile Bo-Kate Wisby returns to Needsville, intent on uniting the Tufa and bringing them out of hiding and into the modern world. The problem? She doesn’t care how many people she has to murder in order to do it.
Longer review: This is the third book by Bledsoe set in the Tufa community of Needsville, Tennessee. The Appalachian setting brings to mind bluegrass music, the majestic isolation of mountain valleys, and shades of the feuding Hatfields & McCoys, creating the perfect atmosphere for an exiled Fairie community to take root in North American soil.
As has been slowly revealed in the previous two books, the Tufa are an Americanized splinter group of the Tuatha de Danann, cast out long ago for the sins of their leader, Rockhouse Hicks.
In the previous book, the tyrannical Hicks lost much of his former power over the community. While many of the Tufa were happy when this happened, exile Bo-Kate Wisby had reason to be the ecstatic. Rockhouse’s fall from power broke the enchantment that kept the psychopathic Bo-Kate from being able to return.
Bo-Kate is full of fury, and determined to take her revenge on the community that cast her out, stole her voice and separated her from the love of her life. She is more than willing to kill anyone who stands up to her, and leaves a trail of bodies through the community as she tries to win enough support to destroy Needsville, once and for all.
Author’s Website: http://alexbledsoe.com/
Read alikes:
American Gods by Neil Gaiman
Almost anything by Charles de Lint
War for the Oaks by Emma Bull
Reviewed by: Teresa Dahlgren, Waterloo Public Library
Review: The Thorn of Dentonhill

Title: The Thorn of Dentonhill
Author: Marshall Ryan
Maresca
Information on series: So
far no series, but a 2nd book set in the same world is due out soon.
Audience: Teen/Adult
Rating: 3
TL;DR: In the city of Maradaine, vigilante Veranix Calbert takes on the
drug dealer who destroyed his family.
Longer review:
Veranix Calbert seems to be
an ordinary student of magic at the University of Maradaine. Few people know of
his tragic history. His father was killed by drug-lord Willem Fenmere, who then
forcibly addicted Veranix’s mother to effitte,
which destroyed her mind. Veranix will do almost anything to bring down
Fenmere’s empire before it destroys more lives.
Fortunately, his early (and
convenient) training as an archer and acrobat in the circus comes in handy. His
magical abilities help him jump to the tops of buildings in a single bound.
Things get more interesting
when Veranix accidentally steals a magical rope and cloak, rather than an effitte shipment. He discovers that
wearing the cloak allows him to do much more magic than he normally can, and
the rope can be directed magically by his thoughts.
Unfortunately for Veranix,
the powerful Blue Hand Circle of mages were the intended recipients of the rope
and cloak. Now, they’re out to find the mysterious “Thorn” in Fenmere’s side,
too.
While the premise of this
book is novel, the execution had problems. The dialogue seemed either clunky or
cheesy most of the time, and it kept me from enjoying the flow of the story.
The names of the characters felt overly contrived. I also had problems
overlooking the Veranix’s clichéd background. All I kept thinking was that it
was a weird mash-up of Batman and Robin’s backstories.
The one bright spot in this
novel, and the reason that I *might* read another book of Mr. Maresca’s was his
portrayal of the Rose Street Princes, one of the street gangs mentioned in the
book. I enjoyed the character of Colin, one of the street captains of the
Princes, who is also Veranix’s cousin. Colin provided a glimmer of hope that
Maresca can create a real character, and not just a caricature.
Read or view alikes:
Any of the “Batman” graphic
novels, although especially the ones in which Bruce Wayne remembers his
parents.
The TV series “Arrow”, or
Netflix series “Daredevil,” for their vigilante themes.
The Iron Druid series by
Kevin Hearne for its pacing and adventure.
Reviewed by: Teresa Dahlgren, Waterloo Public Library
Thursday, July 23, 2015
Review: Catteni Series by Anne McCaffrey
Freedom’s Landing
Freedom’s Choice
Freedom’s Challenge
Freedom’s Ransom
Author: Anne McCaffrey
Information
on Series: Four books, I’m reviewing them as a whole.
Audience:
Adult with YA appeal
Rating:
(scale 1-5 with 5 being the highest): 4
TL;DR: Fast-paced series about a strong female protagonist abducted by aliens, dropped on a planet with other captives, and their fight to survive. Uncomplicated world building, surprisingly upbeat and at times romantic. A good introduction to the writings of Anne McCaffrey with nary a dragon in sight.
Longer
Review: Kristin Bjornsen was kidnapped by the alien Catteni and forced into
slavery on the planet Barevi. Kris did
not meekly accept her fate, she stole her master’s flitter and escaped into the
forest. After months of living, and
surviving on her own, she sees what looks like another Catteni hunting party in flitters flying towards her location. When she looks closer, she realizes on of the flitters is being pursued by the others. Kris saves the Catteni in the pursued flitter, knocks him unconscious, and then tries to return him
to the main city on Barevi. They are both captured by the
Catteni, put to sleep by some drug, loaded into spaceships and then dropped, along with hundreds of
others, on yet another planet. This, my friends, is when the story really
begins.
Initially
the other dropped people (some human, some not) want to kill the Catteni, Zanial. Kris
and a handful of other drops see the wisdom of keeping a Catteni alive for the
time being. Zanial can provide insight
as to what their purpose is on this new planet.
Plus, Kris feels somewhat responsible for his situation even though his race is completely responsible for her situation. Kris is a good person despite what has happened to her. The Catteni deposit slaves on a planet and if they survive then the planet is safe to
inhabit and colonize. If they don’t
survive, the Catteni move on and drop slaves on another planet. The Catteni civilization operates as a caste system,
and Zanial is of the highest caste. A
Catteni has never been dropped before, let alone one of his ranking. Zanial, being pragmatic, says “I dropped, I
stay”. He accepts his fate and helps the
rest of the drops survive.
The
new planet they land on isn’t quite as uninhabited as the Catteni think. Yet another alien race, one nobody has heard of,
uses the planet as a giant farm. There are cow-like creatures, terrifying native birds, and something that sucks all the garbage into the ground at night keeping the planet clean. The garbage cleaner doesn't exactly differentiate between "garbage" and anything else on the ground. When Kris and the others were first dropped, many were sucked into the ground by the garbage cleaner before they woke up from their drugged state. The
first three books chronicle the survival and colonization of this new planet,
dubbed Botany, and Zanial’s desire to spark a rebellion amongst his own people
against the alien race that controls the Catteni. Yes, the Catteni are acting under orders from
a superior race, the Eosi, and Zanial isn’t too happy about being under their thumb. The problem is, Zanial is stuck on Botany with no way to communicate with his fellow Catteni dissenters. Or is he?
This
was my first foray into the writing of Anne McCaffrey. The Catteni series provides some interesting
world building without being totally overwhelming. There is a huge cast of characters and with
each book that cast just gets bigger and bigger. I found that if I just focused on Kris,
Zainal, and a few other main characters, I didn’t get too lost or bogged down
by who was who. The books were written
in the late to mid-1990s (with the exception of book 4) so I enjoyed the pop
culture references. These books are tame
enough for the YA crowd, but they may or may not get some of these
references.
The
fourth book, Freedom’s Ransom, was written about 4 years after the third. It
provided a nice wrap up to the story while still leaving some questions
open to the imagination. There wasn’t
much action and a whole lot of talking. The
story could have easily ended after book 3, but there wasn’t any harm in
finishing off the series. If you are
curious about how Earth survived the Catteni invasion, then book 4 is a must
read.
The Catteni series is about life on other planets and the will to survive. The drops are of different races, but they quickly learn that by working together they will have a better chance of survival. Zanial, as the lone Catteni, manages to make
the best of his terrible situation.
Imagine being the only member of the race that forced everyone else on
Botany into slavery. By accepting his
fate, and following another leader instead of lording over the others, he is accepted as one of the group. I
love that Kris is a strong, capable, well respected female character. She
stands on her own two feet and her strengths are applauded and recognized by
her fellow drops.
I read all four books in about a week making them feel like one long novel which is why I chose to review them as a whole. After Freedom's Landing, each subsequent book contains a preface that summarizes the events from previous books. That would come in handy if you read the series over a long period of time and can't quite remember what happened in a previous book.
I read all four books in about a week making them feel like one long novel which is why I chose to review them as a whole. After Freedom's Landing, each subsequent book contains a preface that summarizes the events from previous books. That would come in handy if you read the series over a long period of time and can't quite remember what happened in a previous book.
The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. Le Guin
While on a mission to the planet Gethen, earthling Genly Ai is sent by leaders of the nation of Orgoreyn to a concentration camp from which exiled prime minister of the nation of Karhide tries to rescue him.
An expert at simulated war games, Andrew "Ender" Wiggins believes that he is engaged in one more computer war game when, in truth, he is commanding the last Earth fleet against an alien race seeking Earth's complete destruction.
The
Quantum Rose by Catherine Asaro
Kamoj
Argali is the young ruler
of an impoverished province on a backward planet. To keep her people from
starving, she has agreed to marry Jax Ironbridge, the boorish and brutal ruler of a prosperous province.
But before Argali and Ironbridge are wed, a mysterious stranger from a distant
planet sweeps in and forces Kamoj into marriage, throwing her world into utter
chaos.
Amy Muchmore, Carnegie-Stout Public Library
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)




